- In "Order Up!", Jesse and Petra visit the Order Hall to show Ivor the cyan enchanted flint and steel.
- In "A Journey's End?", Jesse's gang and Emily (determinant) land inside the Order Hall after they go through their oak wood portal. Afterward, Jesse places all the remaining items in his/her inventory on separate pedestals. Then, the Portal Atlas and the cyan enchanted flint and steel are taken by Ivor.
- In "Hero in Residence", Lukas reads his book to Jesse's gang while in the Order Hall at the beginning of the episode, later, Jesse, Petra, Jack, and Nurm visit the Order Hall to get armor before going to explore the Sea Temple.
- In "Jailhouse Block", Romeo, while posing as Jesse, gives Ivor the amulet of the order to track them down during the after-credits scene in the hall.
- In "Below the Bedrock", Romeo, once again posing as Jesse, reveals himself to Lukas during the after-credits scene in the Order Hall.
The Order Hall is a building located within Beacontown in the Overworld. It is situated next to Ivor's Pad (if Jesse chose to let it stand in "Order Up!"), near the edge of the city. A small river surrounds the front of the building. An extreme hills biome can also be seen in the distance.
The exterior walls of the Order Hall appear to be constructed out of granite and polished granite blocks. The roof of the building appears to be made out of quartz blocks. Out front, a large gold block sculpture can be seen above the main entrance.
The interior walls of the building are mainly constructed out of quartz blocks and stone bricks. The side walls feature several large windows made out of light blue stained glass. Several obsidian support pillars are set in-between these windows. The back of the building contains an expansive window also made out of this stained glass. The floor is made out of diorite and quartz blocks with red carpet placed down the center. An impressive chandelier resembling the amulet can be seen suspended from the roof of the building.
- Dragon Egg
- Ghast Tear
- Prismarine Shards
- Withered Nether Star
- Reuben's Porkchop
- White Pumpkin
- Portal Atlas (Temporarily)
- Redstone Heart
- Eversource Crown
- Cyan Enchanted Flint and Steel (Temporarily)
- Lukas's Journal (Determinant)
- Nether Star
- Golden Apple
- Blaze Rod
- Eyes of Ender
- Lapis Lazuli (Formerly)
- Ender Pearl (Formerly)
- Sponges (Formerly)
- Pufferfish (Formerly)
- Spider Eye (Formerly)
- Official Banners of Boom Town or Redstonia
- In "Order Up!", The Order Hall contains two empty displays.
- These are later occupied by a third nether star and a diamond.
- The side walls will feature banners from either Boom Town or Redstonia.
- Additionally, the amulet banner, Gabriel's banner, and a blaze rod banner can all be seen along the side walls as well.
- The presence of both the blaze rod and its associated banner may have been foreshadowing events later in Episode 5 involving The Blaze Rods.
- The ender pearl on display is spherical, and not flat like it is in any other episodes.
- An enderman mob head can also be seen on display.
- In Minecraft, enderman mob heads do not exist, making them exclusive to Minecraft: Story Mode.
- Many of the trophies on display used to belong to Ivor. It can be presumed that Ivor willingly gave them to Jesse's gang once they became The New Order of the Stone.
- Entering the Overworld's portal from The Portal Network will put whomever entered it in the center of the room.
- In "Order Up!", several pedestals were occupied with two sponges, a spider eye, a pufferfish, and lapis lazuli. When Jesse returns to the Overworld from the Portal Hallway, those displays are now missing.
- The Order Hall's name was confirmed by Eric Stirpe on Tumblr: File:OrderHallConfirmed.png
- It has been revealed on Tumblr by Eric Stirpe that Jesse's Gang lived in the Order Hall after the Wither Storm event.